Theory as History: Essays on Modes of Production & Exploitation. Jairus Banaji; Historical Materialism Book Series, Volume 25, Leiden, Brill, xix plus The essays demonstrate the importance of reintegrating theory with history and of bringing history back into historical materialism. Jairus Banaji. BRILL, Theory as History: Essays on Modes of Production and Exploitation. Book · January Jairus Banaji at University of London Content uploaded by Jairus Banaji.
|Published (Last):||25 January 2005|
|PDF File Size:||17.73 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.56 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
You get a much better sense of what capitalism is like in China today, at the fag end of several decades of state accumulation and repression, than from any number of texts histoyr simply reiterate the most rudimentary commonplaces of theory.
Other books in the series.
Theory as History – Essays on Modes of Production and Exploitation
John Haldon – – Historical Materialism 21 4: This argument is the thread that keeps these otherwise unrelated scholarly essays together. I have to say that this book is the single most inspiring piece of historical materialist theory that I have ever read since reading Marx’s own “18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte.
Sep 25, C. Alan Carling – – Science and Society 57 1: Whatever the case may be, here appears a weakness in the book: Bob Reutenauer rated it really liked it Jan 19, This argument is the thread that keeps these otherwise unrelated scholarly essays together.
Return to Book Page.
Theory As History: Essays on Modes of Production and Exploitation
What Kind of Transition? Eva rated it it was amazing Jan 30, So if production remains central to the strategies of the Left, this is where we have to start. View all 4 comments. If credit is the basis of modern capitalist economies, then the financial markets are central to accumulation and we have to be able to understand how they work. I have also long considered the possibility of conceptualizing a separate mode of production to describe the societies dominated by mercantile capital only, roughly histtory s in northern Italy etc to or so; perhaps a ‘mercantilist mode of production’ or somesuch.
This is ironic because when he goes on to deal with the thsory, he makes reproduction the central category. Jairus Banaji has been a prolific and brilliant writer on economic historical topics for almost 40 years now, so a publication of some of his core articles and essays seemed long overdue.
But that characterisation, though true in some very rudimentary sense, is simply not enough. Analytical Marxism and Ecology: Contract, Coercion and so-called Unfree Labour 6. Here some more decisive empirical evidence might be needed.
I also think that Banaji’s looser definition of capitalism frustrates all kinds of other Marxists particularly when looking at over-generalizations in other modes of production. Neeladri Bhattacharya – – Historical Materialism 21 4: So I see my work as a unified intervention at very different levels, in rather different fields. Bill Crane rated it it was amazing Jun 19, The two most powerful capitalist states in the world today China and the US emerged through radically different histories.
Elle rated it it was amazing Sep 17, Books by Jairus Banaji.
Philosophy of History in Philosophy of Social Science categorize this paper. Fred rated it liked it Dec 16, The precondition for its own growth as a major political force in the world today lies in the emergence of new working classes or new layers of the working class that recover some sense of their own collective initiative and power and of what it means to be a class that can aspire to shape society.
Bart rated it really liked it Dec 04, An introductory chapter ties the collection together and shows how historical materialists can develop an alternative to Marx’s ‘Asiatic mode of production’. Another major point, immediately connected with the former, is Banaji’s efforts to establish the prevalence of various forms of wage-labour throughout history, as well as the prevalence of what he considers to be capitalist forms of exploitation in pre-capitalist modes of production.
Withoutabox Submit to Film Festivals. Amazon Inspire Digital Educational Resources.
Theory as History
Showing of 2 reviews. An introductory chapter ties the collection together and shows how historical materialists can develop an alternative to Marx’s ‘Asiatic mode of production’. What is denied is any rigid succession of modes of production. Furthermore, Banaji seems to reject teleologies as such.
But pre-modern capitalism has been widespread in many parts of the world from China under the Southern Sung to large sectors of the Muslim world, cf. It also calls for Marxists to look at non-European societies and do more significant comparative work before making big claims about history. Banaji’s descripti I have to say that this book is the single most inspiring piece of historical materialist theory that I have ever read since reading Marx’s own “18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte.
Jairus Banaji, Theory as History: Essays on Modes of Production and Exploitation – PhilPapers
Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. That said, this book is a brilliant contribution to Marxist historiography as well as a great collection of often astonishingly erudite contributions to Marxist economic history, and is well worth reading by anyone interested in historiography, agricultural history, or Marxism, or any combination of these.
Varn rated it really liked it. Historical Materialism and Capital. How today can we isolate capital from the state or the state theorj the media or the media from capital?