2nd edition, Summary Family and Civilization is the magnum opus of Carle Zimmerman , a distinguished sociologist who taught for many. Family and Civilization is the magnum opus of Carle Zimmerman, a distinguished sociologist who taught for many years at Harvard University. Family and Civilization by Carle C. Zimmerman, The Family of. Tomorrow by Carle C. Zimmerman (review). Eva J. Ross. The Thomist: A Speculative Quarterly .
|Published (Last):||7 May 2011|
|PDF File Size:||5.54 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.63 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
If we violate a rule, who punishes us, the darle or the state? Morgan illustrates this point from the other side of the Atlantic. Click here to sign up. The very idea of liberty itself changes, according to Zimmerman:. It is manifestly untrue to say that a determined abnormal person can civilizationn establish atypical types of behavior in nonliterate groups.
This impacts marital and reproductive ethics, but it ought to also inform our theories of political rights, representation, and economics.
Carle Zimmerman, Family and Civilization | Stephen Baskerville –
He lays out his key analytical questions in the second chapter:. And he shows the consequences of each structure for the bearing and rearing of children; for religion, law, and everyday life; and for the fate of civilization itself.
A Journal of World Affairs. Against both the civilizarion trustee and Roman atomistic family systems, the Church introduced the idea that children are automatically social ckvilization, the children of their mother and her husband, and could not be rejected.
When first published inFamily and Civilization was a significant book on the sociology of the family. If we want to marry or break up a family, whom do we consult, the family, the church or the state? Zimmerman escapes this trap by focusing on the sovereignty of the family. Without cookies your experience may not be seamless. Zimmerman Harper and Brothers, New York, The essential arguments of this book, including the characteristics and the causes of the three main types of family found in Western civilization designated Trustee, Domestic and Atomisticas well as the dangers of the last and most recent type and the zimmermqn in which they may be avoided, have been presented in summary by the skilled writers camily one of the most popular American magazines Life, July 26, In this unjustly forgotten work Zimmerman demonstrates the close and causal connections between the rise and fall of different types of families and the rise and fall of civilizations, particularly ancient Greece and Rome, medieval and modern Europe, and the United States.
This book takes the reader from the genesis of the family and civilization to its apocalyptic destination.
Family and Civilization
In essence, the remedy is that if civilization is to be saved, the family pattern must be changed. A study of them can tell us nothing about our past. Yet Carle Zimmerman, who would not have been surprised at this, provides a profound and excellent guide to those wishing to restore a culture of familism. It used to be the fashion to juxtapose tribal communities as a whole against so-called higher cultures as a whole.
He willingly follows any prophet and they are mostly false ones who comes along with a sure-cure nostrum for the diseases of the social system. Zimmerman saw that not everyone in society actually participates in familism, meaning the social system that brings forth the next generation: Over and over, Zimmerman In modern Europe birth rates have been falling since the late points out how the state views the family as a threat, how nineteenth century and were below replacement level by the state eviscerates the family, the state sponsors anti- Morgan shows that under the influence of policies like these, the proportion of one-person households in the United Kingdom increased from 14 percent in to 30 percent by Lance Kinzer rated it it was amazing Sep 11, Pages which deserve careful reading in view of current discussion of the relativt: The family reappears by counterrevolution.
Jun 14, Edward Waverley marked it as to-read Shelves: View freely available titles: A Text for Moderns. The numbers before the comments correspond to the numbers before the assumptions quoted above: The individual, having no guiding moral principles, changes the meaning of freedom from opportunity to license. This falloff reflected a larger renunciation of the family intellectuals, the state seeks supremacy over the family as a social and personal institution, what Zimmerman family and society in general.
He understands only the pleasurable and receiving aspects of the family system and few or none of the sacrificial pleasurable in a different sense and giving aspects of the family.
Dec 29, Steven Wedgeworth rated it it was amazing. For families to sustain themselves becomes progressively more difficult.
Zimmerman shows why this happens, not only in the United Kingdom of the twentieth century but also in post-Revolutionary France and in many other historical settings. Be the first to ask a question about Family and Civilization. Jordan Harmer rated it really liked it Jun 06, It is impossible in any review to suggest the wealth of profound spiritual guidance available to souls in a work of this zimmermsn.
The state wishes to show no favoritism toward marriage and no animus toward unmarried mothers. Help Center Find new research papers in: The domestic family and the atomistic family would correspond roughly to the modern family before and after the sexual revolution.
Things are getting better because they are getting freer, which means more contractual. The most incisive guide to issues facing the American family today.